Eight Weeks in the Tenderloin
Middle schoolers, paint and VR in an after-school program with the Boys & Girls Club.
By Lisa Davis
Eight weeks does not sound like a long time, unless you are spending it with middle schoolers, in which case it is roughly a geological era. Friendships begin and end. Crushes rise and fall like empires. Someone grows two inches. And somewhere in there, if you are lucky, a group of twelve-year-olds decides that art is not embarrassing after all.
I ran an eight-week after-school program with the Boys & Girls Club and Tech in the Tenderloin, in one of San Francisco’s most misunderstood neighborhoods. The plan was to mix two worlds: traditional 2D art, with paper and paint and markers, and virtual reality, where you can draw in the air and walk inside your own picture. The goal was self-expression and a little emotional resilience. The secret goal was fun, because nobody that age will stick with anything for eight weeks unless it is fun.

I love starting with paper. VR is dazzling, and dazzling can hide a lot. Paper is honest. It shows you exactly what your hand did, and middle schoolers, who are already being judged on everything from their shoes to their voices, often need a little time before they will risk making a mark that might be wrong. So you make a lot of marks that might be wrong. Then you make some more. Somewhere along the way, wrong stops mattering.
Then the headsets come out, and the room changes. There is nothing quite like watching a kid who has been told over and over what they can’t do suddenly discover a place with no edges at all. They can make something the size of a building. They can stand inside it. They can invite a friend in. The 2D work builds confidence, and VR gives that confidence somewhere enormous to go.
The research on programs like this is encouraging. Robin Wright and her colleagues evaluated a nine-month community arts program for young people aged nine to fifteen in low-income neighborhoods. Compared with a comparison group, the participants improved their art skills and their social skills and showed fewer behavioral and emotional problems (Wright et al., 2006). Our program was much shorter, and I won’t pretend it changed anyone’s life in eight weeks. But I believe in what that study points to. Give young people a real way to make things, alongside adults who take them seriously, and good things start to grow.
Kids in neighborhoods like the Tenderloin hear a lot about what is wrong with where they live. They deserve to hear far more about what is right with who they are. Art is one of the most direct ways I know to show them. Here is a blank page. Here is a whole blank world. Show me what you see.
They always do. You just have to give them eight weeks, some markers, a headset, and the patience to survive a few dozen dramatic sighs.
Reference
Wright, R., John, L., Alaggia, R., & Sheel, J. (2006). Community-based arts program for youth in low-income communities: A multi-method evaluation. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 23(5–6), 635–652. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10560-006-0079-0



