Skip to content

Thoughts

Landfill Rescue

Broken necklaces and lone earrings get a second life in a frame.

By Lisa Davis

Almost everyone has the drawer. You know the one. A single earring whose partner left without a forwarding address. A chain knotted so badly it has become a sculpture. A brooch that belonged to somebody you loved, too old-fashioned to wear and too important to throw away. So it sits there, in the dark, waiting for a decision nobody wants to make.

I make that decision all the time now, and the answer is almost always the same. Don’t throw it away. Frame it.

I have a truly alarming amount of broken jewelry. Rhinestones without settings, beads without strings, clasps without anything to clasp. Jewelry is one of those things that is nearly impossible to recycle the ordinary way, a little tangle of mixed metals and glass and plastic and glue, so when it breaks, it tends to head for the landfill. I can’t stand the thought of all that sparkle sitting in the dark forever. It deserves better. It deserves a wall.

Two people holding framed art made from upcycled jewelry, a bunny and a heart
A bunny and a heart that used to be somebody’s jewelry box.

When you lay those pieces out on a dark background and start arranging them, something happens. A string of faux pearls becomes the curve of a heart. Rhinestones become a rabbit’s eye. A tarnished pin becomes the star on top of a tree. The pieces stop being broken and start being parts. That’s the whole magic trick, and I never get tired of watching it work on people.

There is a lovely piece of research about why it works. Michael Norton, Daniel Mochon and Dan Ariely asked people to build things, IKEA boxes and origami cranes and Lego sets, and then asked what those things were worth. People valued what they had made themselves far more than identical things made by someone else, sometimes nearly as much as work by experts. The researchers called it the IKEA effect. The catch was that the love only showed up when people finished. Half-built things didn’t get the glow (Norton et al., 2012).

I think about that every time someone holds up a finished frame. Of course they love it. They made it. But there’s something more going on with jewelry, because these pieces already carried a history before they ever reached my table. Somebody wore that earring to a wedding. Somebody got that brooch for a birthday. Somebody fastened that chain in a mirror, on a morning that mattered. A frame doesn’t erase any of that. It finally gives it somewhere to be seen.

So go open the drawer. Take out the orphans and the tangles and the things you can’t bear to lose. They aren’t junk. They’re waiting. Bring them to me, and we’ll rescue them from the landfill one rhinestone at a time.

Reference

Norton, M. I., Mochon, D., & Ariely, D. (2012). The IKEA effect: When labor leads to love. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 22(3), 453–460. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcps.2011.08.002

ShareFacebookLinkedInXTextEmail